Chapter Four · failure evidence

What Polymerization Techniques got wrong, from 80 dissertations

Across the records, polymer synthesis and processing methods frequently encounter difficulties such as premature termination, unexpected side reactions, and structural defects. Many experimental techniques struggle with poor interfacial adhesion, incomplete network formation, and colloidal instability during material fabrication. These records come from PhD theses at 18 institutions, 2021 to 2026. Each links to its thesis. They were extracted by language models reading the full text, so treat each as a lead to read, not a verdict.

Controlled and free radical polymerizations fail due to side reactions, radical quenching, and mediator limitations

17 theses · 12 institutions

Free radical and controlled radical polymerizations often suffer from catalyst poisoning, deoxygenation inconsistency, and metal or initiator toxicity that damages encapsulated biologics. Attempts to control chain growth or use photoredox catalysts frequently result in negligible monomer conversion, unmediated propagation, or severe degradation of sensitive components.

Tried and failed

nitrogen bubbling deoxygenation applied to atom transfer radical polymerization. Outcome: unstable. Reason: incomplete or variable oxygen removal led to batch-to-batch kinetic inconsistency and low-molecular-weight tailing

Polymer-Ligated Nanocrystals with Tunable Dimensions, Compositions, and Architectures · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

radical polymerization of functionalized aromatic monomers applied to monomers lacking a flexible alkyl spacer. Reason: absence of a flexible spacer between the polymerizable group and aromatic core inhibited radical polymerization

Controlling the Properties of Polymer Metal-Organic Frameworks and Cages Through Polymer Ligand Design · MIT

Tried and failed

reversible deactivation radical polymerization network synthesis applied to crosslinked polymer network mechanical properties. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: controlled growth delayed percolation leading to more brittle networks and increased molecular damage under strain

Leveraging living copolymerizations as a tool to tailor the architecture and mechanical properties of polymer networks · UT Austin

Tried and failed

covalent template-directed free-radical polymerization applied to sequence-controlled polymer synthesis. Reason: inter-template propagation or radical recombination caused product degree of polymerization to exceed template length

Covalent Template-Directed Synthesis: A Powerful Tool for the Construction of Complex Molecules. · Cambridge

Tried and failed

macromolecular photoinitiator steric shielding of encapsulated molecules applied to photocrosslinkable hydrogel photo-switch encapsulation. Outcome: unstable. Reason: cleaved radical fragment lacking the bulky polymer group caused radical degradation of sensitive encapsulated photoswitches

Donor-acceptor stenhouse adducts: a basis for dynamic, light-switchable hydrogels · Imperial

Tried and failed

anionic and radical polymerization applied to sulfinyl diene monomers. Reason: no polymer product formed under initiator conditions

Functional Polymer Materials: From Iptycenes to Ring-Opening Polymerizations · MIT

Tried and failed

photoredox ATRP using organic photosensitizers alone applied to controlled radical polymerization of methacrylates. Reason: insufficient photocatalytic activity or energy transfer without quantum dot photocatalysts resulted in negligible monomer conversion

Synthesis, Properties, and Assemblies of Uniform Polymer-ligated Nanocrystals · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

low concentration initiator and accelerator free-radical polymerization applied to salt-containing hydrogel synthesis. Reason: insufficient active radicals formed to overcome salt inhibition and induce gelation

Physics and Engineering of Moisture-Capturing Hydrogels for Water and Heat Harvesting · MIT

Lost to a baseline

Acrylate-NBE monomers showed lower grafting efficiency and slower polymerization kinetics than non-photolabile acrylate systems (such as PEGMA or acrylic acid) due to radical inhibition by nitro groups.

Photo-responsive polymer networks for the design of polymer coatings with light-tunable properties · IRIS - POLITO - prod

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected grafting-from radical polymerization on anisotropic metal nanoparticles because free radicals rigorously etch the metal.

Thin-Film Polymer Nanocomposites Composed of Two-Dimensional Plasmonic Nanoparticles and Graphene · Virginia Tech

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: ATRP living radical polymerization was rejected due to reported disadvantages concerning metal contaminants.

Synthesis and self-assembly of hydrophobically modified polybetaines · Texas Tech

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected controlled radical polymerisations (ATRP, RAFT, NMP) in favour of GTP due to slower kinetics, transition metal toxicity/removal issues (ATRP), and toxic/odorous thiol CTAs (RAFT)

Effects of composition and architecture on the thermo-induced aggregation of thermoresponsive OEGMA-based block terpolymers · Imperial

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected methacrylated alginate cryogel crosslinking via TEMED and APS redox free-radical polymerization for T cell encapsulation due to generation of free radicals that react with and damage encapsulated proteins; adopted tetrazine-norbornene click chemistry.

Modulating T cell Therapies with Biomaterials · Harvard

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected UV photopolymerization (e.g., of gelatin methacrylate) due to toxic radical photoinitiators preventing germinal center response.

Immune Organoids to Study Antigen Presentation · Cornell

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Acrylic co-polymers formed via radical polymerization as phosphor embedding matrices, rejected due to photoluminescence quenching from radical initiators.

Optical and Structural Studies of Shape-Controlled Semiconductor Nanocrystals and Their Self-Assembled Solids · Penn

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Discarded DDMAT as RAFT agent for copolymerizations due to inability to control MMA methacrylates.

Synthesis of random and block copolymers from terpene-based and acrylate-based monomers · University of Nottingham Repository

Tried and failed

exponential feed rate of control agent applied to reversible deactivation radical polymerization. Reason: lag in regulator accumulation caused initial unmediated polymerization, yielding bimodal distributions

Investigating the Structure-Property Relationships in Thermoplastic Elastomers and Polymers for Explosion-Resistant Coatings · Cornell

Ring-opening and metathesis polymerizations encounter monomer decomposition, reactivity mismatches, and equilibrium limitations

12 theses · 6 institutions

Ring-opening metathesis reactions frequently suffer from backbiting, cross-metathesis side reactions, and monomer deactivation caused by polar or electron-withdrawing substituents. Monomer reactivity ratio disparities and ring-chain equilibrium constraints also lead to compositional drift, low overall conversions, and insoluble gel formation.

Tried and failed

acid-catalyzed ring-opening metathesis polymerization applied to strained cyclopropenes. Outcome: unstable. Reason: monomer decomposed under reaction conditions yielding no polymer

Exploration of Carbonyl–Olefin Metathesis Reactions: Ring Opening, Ring Closing and Polymerization. Investigation of Cyclopropenimines for Carbon Dioxide Capture and Its Conjugate · Cornell

Tried and failed

living ring-opening metathesis at high dilution applied to high molecular weight polymer synthesis. Outcome: unstable. Reason: dominant backbiting and cross-metathesis side reactions led to loss of polymerization control

Biomimetic elastomers from ring-opening metathesis polymerization · UT Austin

Tried and failed

ring-opening polymerization at low monomer-to-initiator ratio applied to asymmetric cyclic diester polymerization. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: low monomer loading promoted dominant transesterification side-reactions, reducing regioselectivity and increasing dispersity

POLYESTER SEQUENCE CONTROL VIA REGIO- AND STEREOSELECTIVE RING-OPENING POLYMERIZATIONS · Cornell

Tried and failed

ring-opening metathesis polymerization using ruthenium catalyst applied to bridged bicyclic ketone monomers. Reason: insufficient ring strain or unfavorable electronics compared to twisted amide analogues prevented polymerization

Synthesis, reactivity and polymerization of bridged bicyclic twisted amides · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

short duration ring opening metathesis polymerization applied to electron withdrawing functionalized norbornene monomers. Outcome: too slow. Reason: electron-withdrawing nitrile groups deactivate catalyst or slow metathesis kinetics requiring extended reaction times

Characterizing Mechanical and Gas Transport Properties of Nitrile Norbornene (NN) ROMP in Preparation for Analysis of OMe-NN-ROMP Block Copolymers · MIT

Tried and failed

ring-opening metathesis polymerization applied to 1,5-cyclooctadiene monomer. Reason: formed viscous fluids rather than handleable solid polymers

Spatially defined crystallinity within multimaterial polymeric networks · UT Austin

Tried and failed

stereoselective ring-opening metathesis polymerization applied to cis-cyclooctene polymerization. Outcome: too slow. Reason: catalysts exhibited low catalytic activity yielding low monomer conversions even at elevated temperatures

Spatially defined crystallinity within multimaterial polymeric networks · UT Austin

Tried and failed

sterically hindered branching agent in graft-through polymerization applied to ring-opening metathesis star polymer synthesis. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: branching agent reduced monomer reactivity, suppressing propagation and yielding incompletely converted intermediates

The design and application of functional enyne reagents in metathesis polymerization · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

driving copolymerization to high conversion applied to random ring-opening copolymer synthesis. Reason: reactivity ratio disparity causes compositional drift and loss of random copolymer architecture at high conversion

RATIONAL DESIGN OF HIGH-PERFORMANCE AMORPHOUS POLYMER ELECTROLYTES · Cornell

Tried and failed

metathesis polymerization at higher monomer concentrations applied to functionalized cyclic olefin monomers. Reason: produced insoluble gel-like materials preventing solution characterization

Characterizing Mechanical and Gas Transport Properties of Nitrile Norbornene (NN) ROMP in Preparation for Analysis of OMe-NN-ROMP Block Copolymers · MIT

Tried and failed

seven-membered cyclic comonomers in ring-opening metathesis copolymerization applied to cleavable random copolymer synthesis. Reason: mismatched reactivity ratios and high equilibrium monomer concentrations caused gradient rather than random copolymerization

Entropy Drives the Predictive Discovery of an Optimal Cleavable Comonomer for ROMP · MIT

Tried and failed

Selective vinyl polymerization from monomer mixture applied to unseparated lactone monomer mixture. Reason: Concurrent ring-opening polymerization occurred at room temperature, causing crosslinking and low monomer recovery yields

Synthesis of α-methylene-δ-valerolactone and its selective polymerization from a product mixture for concurrent separation and polymer production · MIT

Tried and failed

extending reaction time to increase conversion applied to anionic ring-opening polymerization. Reason: monomer conversion plateaued due to ring-chain equilibrium

RATIONAL DESIGN OF HIGH-PERFORMANCE AMORPHOUS POLYMER ELECTROLYTES · Cornell

Tried and failed

rare-earth alkoxide catalyzed ring-opening polymerization applied to vinyl-functionalized lactone monomers. Reason: catalyst failed to selectively trigger ring opening over vinyl-addition across tested temperatures

Synthesis of α-methylene-δ-valerolactone and its selective polymerization from a product mixture for concurrent separation and polymer production · MIT

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected diblock copolymer synthesis via poly(6)-PCO route due to poor monomer conversion (<40%), low reaction yields, and intractable polymer insolubility after oxidation

Development of additives for the controlled degradation of polyethylene · Imperial

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected direct polymerization of cyclic monomers bearing polar groups due to low polymer yields (e.g., 3-37%).

High Permittivity Siloxanes as Promising Materials for Dielectric Elastomer Transducers: From Synthesis to Application · EPFL

Hydrogel crosslinking and photopolymerization processes fail from curing interference, thermal exotherms, and network defects

15 theses · 10 institutions

Photopolymerization in watery or filled networks is frequently hindered by moisture inhibition, light attenuation, and unmoderated reaction exotherms exceeding the lower critical solution temperature. In addition, unbalanced precursor formulations and excessive vinyl substitution result in uncontrolled thermoset gelation, structural tearing, or failure to form cohesive networks.

Tried and failed

trans-tissue photopolymerization of synthetic hydrogels applied to in situ hydrogel formation through tissue. Reason: Severe light attenuation through tissue and low reactive group density prevented polymerization

Engineered synthetic hydrogel platform for human intestinal organoids in vitro culture and in vivo therapeutic delivery · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

interpenetrating polymer network hydrogel fabrication applied to multi-component extracellular matrix hydrogels. Reason: failed to form true interpenetrating networks despite retaining components without macroscopic phase separation

Inferring dynamic extracellular matrix composition of the thymus: towards a biomimetic scaffold for T cell culture · Harvard

Tried and failed

plasma surface modification for demoulding release applied to photopolymerised micro-moulded hydrogels. Reason: insufficient anti-stiction without silanisation caused hydrogel tearing during mould release

Development of a micro-patterned hydrogel scaffold to guide photoreceptor polarization for treatment of macular degeneration · Imperial

Lost to a baseline

EMI-composite showed lower final storage modulus than EMI-ionogel due to ceramic aggregates blocking UV penetration during photopolymerization.

Towards Solid-State Hybrid Polymer Electrolytes by Innovative, Rapid, and Solvent-Free Procedures · IRIS - POLITO - prod

Tried and failed

room temperature polymerization without thermal regulation applied to thermoresponsive hydrogel synthesis. Reason: polymerization exotherm heated the reaction mixture above its lower critical solution temperature, causing phase separation and opacity

Sensor-Enabled Accelerated Engineering of Soft Materials · Virginia Tech

Tried and failed

direct sequential photopolymerisation without an intermediate adhesive applied to hydrophobic-hydrophilic bilayer actuators. Reason: post-curing degraded interfacial radical availability or excessively crosslinked the hydrogel, impairing responsiveness

3D printed stimuli-responsive biomaterials for programmable drug delivery · Imperial

Tried and failed

single-network polymer hydrogel without porous templating applied to hydrogel water release under mechanical stress. Outcome: unstable. Reason: Lack of sponge-like channels prevents force-induced water release, causing structural fragmentation under stress.

Material design and molecular engineering of hydrogels for solar desalination · UT Austin

Tried and failed

multivalent cation crosslinking of biopolymer hydrogels applied to hydrogel bead synthesis. Outcome: unstable. Reason: insufficient polymer or crosslinker concentration failed to form stable gel network

The Valorization of Agricultural by Products for the Removal of Inorganic Phosphate from Water · Scholarship at UWindsor Institutional Repository

Tried and failed

thermoresponsive diblock and statistical copolymer synthesis applied to hydrogel sol-gel transition. Outcome: no signal. Reason: copolymers failed to undergo physical gelation or form stable networks across tested concentrations and temperatures

Identifying design criteria for ethylene glycol-based methacrylate thermoresponsive polymer · Imperial

Tried and failed

solvent-free thermal bulk polymerization without initiator applied to vinyl monomer network synthesis. Reason: produced an inhomogeneous, glassy product instead of a uniform polymer network

Fracture of Highly Entangled Polymer Networks · Harvard

Tried and failed

tuning block copolymer composition balance for thermogelation applied to symmetric multiblock terpolymer hydrogels. Reason: excess hydrophobicity or hydrophilicity disrupted network formation, causing precipitation instead of gelation

Effects of composition and architecture on the thermo-induced aggregation of thermoresponsive OEGMA-based block terpolymers · Imperial

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Using HA polymer concentrations exceeding 3% was rejected because the resulting high viscosity hindered experimental operations and caused hydrogel non-uniformity and structural defects.

Tough Injectable Hydrogels by Combining Elastic and Energy Dissipation · Research Repository UCD

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected full acrylation of lignin bio-oil hydroxyls because multiple polymerizable vinyl sites per oligomer caused uncontrolled crosslinking and thermoset gelation instead of linear thermoplastics.

Lignin valorization for carbon based materials · Iowa State

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected cationic photopolymerization because moisture in watery hydrogel structures inhibits the reaction.

PHOTOCURABLE HYDROGELS FOR TISSUE ENGINERING APPLICATIONS · IRIS - POLITO - prod

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected standard ProExM single-gel polymerization because sodium acrylate destabilized the hyaluronan filler network.

Expansion Microscopy of Extracellular Space for Light Microscopy-Based Connectomic Analysis · MIT

Polymer film coating and surface functionalization techniques fail due to poor wettability and interfacial debonding

12 theses · 7 institutions

Polymer solutions applied to substrates often suffer from dewetting, sliding off low-energy surfaces, or developing non-uniform coverage during spin-coating and slot-die deposition. Coatings and interlayers also delaminate readily during solvent exposure, wire bonding, or plating because of weak interfacial adhesion and poor surface activation.

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected oxygen plasma alone or Ar-O2 plasma without vacuum baking prior to Ti/Cu sputtering because they failed to significantly increase seed-layer adhesion to polymer dielectrics.

Design and Demonstration of Mechanical and Electrical Reliability of 1-micron Redistribution Layers · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

aqueous nanoparticle coating without emulsifier applied to reinforcing fibers for polymer composites. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: uneven caking and poor surface coverage reduced interfacial adhesion compared to uncoated fibers

Nanocellulose-based Glass Fiber Sizing for Lightweight Fiberglass Composites · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

sequential polymer coating of particulate aggregate applied to thermoplastic aggregate composites. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: poor interfacial adhesion between incompatible polymer matrix layers reduced compressive strength

Potential transition to a circular economy for plastics in developing countries: recycling plastic waste into plastic-bonded aggregate composites for construction · Imperial

Tried and failed

low crosslinker content polymer film coating applied to sensor surface in solvent environment. Outcome: unstable. Reason: film suffered delamination from the substrate surface upon solvent soaking

Synthesis and characterization of modular, functionalizable polymer membranes for specific solute capture · UT Austin

Tried and failed

slot-die coating on low-energy substrates applied to low-viscosity photopolymer resins. Reason: The low-viscosity fluid failed to wet the low-surface-energy fluoropolymer film and slid off.

Large-volume LCD additive manufacturing : printing high-viscosity and low-reactivity elastomeric resins · UT Austin

Tried and failed

hydrolysed pure polymer linker for MOF coating applied to superhydrophobic MOF surface coatings. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: absence of elastomeric polymer co-component resulted in hydrophilic rather than superhydrophobic surface properties

UPCYCLING DISCARDED POLYESTER TEXTILES INTO METAL-ORGANIC FRAMEWORKS AND ELECTROSPUN NANOFIBERS · Cornell

Tried and failed

spin-coating thin films from dilute polymer solutions applied to substrate surface coating. Reason: High concentrations caused non-uniformity from excess viscosity, while low concentrations failed to wet the wafer surface properly

Surfactant migration on polymeric substrates · Imperial

Tried and failed

excessive aqueous dilution of polymer solution applied to conducting polymer thin film deposition. Reason: insufficient film coverage and poor wettability over the substrate

Organic and hybrid semiconductors for photovoltaic application — control of energetics and interfacial properties · Imperial

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected polymer insulating coating on stainless steel electrode holders because it debonded at the nozzle exit causing short circuits, replaced by epoxy resin moulding via metallographic press

Enhanced surface finishing of bearing raceways · Cranfield

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected gelatin capsules for direct Eudragit coating due to poor polymer adhesion

Bowel MRI imaging to investigate drug delivery from coated capsules · University of Nottingham Repository

Tried and failed

polymer surface passivation applied to semiconductor device fabrication. Outcome: unstable. Reason: poor interfacial adhesion during subsequent wire bonding processes

Development, Fabrication and Characterization of III-Nitride Bipolar Devices: Rectifiers, Avalanche Photodiodes, and Laser Diodes · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

direct metal electroplating on conducting polymer interlayers applied to multilayer metal polymer laminated structures. Reason: insufficient surface activation and nucleation failure on specific surfactant-doped polymer surfaces

Additively Fabricated Laminated Inductors For Miniaturized Switching Power Converters · Penn

Interfacial polymerization and membrane fabrication techniques produce selective layer defects and substrate fouling

10 theses · 6 institutions

Interfacial polymerization reactions can lead to membrane defects and poor salt rejection when using branched monomers, fluorinated chains, or incompatible support surfaces. In addition, casting solvents and large macromolecular aggregates can dissolve the underlying porous support or irreversibly block pores during membrane synthesis.

Tried and failed

immersion interfacial polymerization without solvent solubility tuning applied to porous substrate surface coating. Outcome: no signal. Reason: insufficient poor-solvent fraction prevented polymer precipitation onto the substrate

Spatially-Directed Interfacial Polymerization · MIT

Tried and failed

solution deposition on polymeric porous substrate applied to thin film composite membrane fabrication. Reason: the casting solvent rapidly dissolved the underlying polymer support layer

Ion-selective membranes for hydrogen-metal hybrid redox flow batteries · Imperial

Tried and failed

vapor phase infiltration treatment applied to polyimide separation membrane supports. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: low precursor diffusivity into the polymer matrix and lack of favorable chemical binding sites

Designing Organic Solvent Reverse Osmosis Membranes for The Separation of Liquid Hydrocarbons · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

incorporating long fluorinated chains into interfacial polymerization monomers applied to ultrathin polyamide membrane synthesis. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: poor precursor solubility and slow interfacial diffusion prevented defect-free film formation, lowering permeance

Development of ultrathin polyamide membranes incorporating multi-oligomer amines for organic solvent nanofiltration · Imperial

Tried and failed

aqueous self-assembly of block copolymers applied to continuous membrane fabrication. Reason: polymers preferentially assembled into isolated micelles and vesicles rather than continuous planar membrane structures

Bioinspired membrane design, synthesis, and characterization to control microstructure and enable efficient molecular separations · UT Austin

Tried and failed

interfacial polymerization using branched multifunctional monomers applied to thin-film composite desalination membranes. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: membrane defect formation led to poor salt rejection

Structure-Property Relationships in the Design of High Performance Membranes for Water Desalination, Specifically Reverse Osmosis, Using Sulfonated Poly(Arylene Ether Sulfone)s · Virginia Tech

Tried and failed

interfacial polymerization without surface pre-treatment applied to large-pore or acidic membrane supports. Reason: proton interference and excessive pore size prevented defect-free selective layer formation

Nanostructured solvent-stable membranes for solvent permeation and pharmaceutical separation · Imperial

Tried and failed

two-step coating of ionic liquid on polymer applied to gas separation membranes. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: interfacial incompatibility between ionic liquid and unmodified polymer caused defective, uncovered membrane regions

Design, Fabrication, Scale-Up, and Process Integration of Nanoconfined Ionic Liquid Membranes for CO2 Separation from Industrial Flue Gas · DSpace at SUNY Buffalo

Tried and failed

nonsolvent-induced phase separation with poor nonsolvent miscibility applied to block copolymer membrane fabrication. Reason: low solvent miscibility with the coagulation bath prevented pore formation, producing dense non-porous films

Polymers for water and energy systems · UT Austin

Tried and failed

direct in-situ interfacial polymerization on porous support applied to nanofiltration membrane fabrication. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: large self-assembled macromolecular aggregates blocked support pores smaller than their size

Development of ultrathin polyamide membranes incorporating multi-oligomer amines for organic solvent nanofiltration · Imperial

Tried and failed

vapor phase infiltration of metal precursors applied to microporous polymer membranes. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: titanium precursor infiltration failed to enhance polymer resistance to organic solvent dissolution

Designing the Structure of Inorganic Clusters Within Vapor Phase Infiltrated Polymer Membranes to Control Properties · Georgia Tech

Emulsion and dispersion polymerizations suffer from droplet coalescence, latex coagulation, and uncontrolled phase separation

9 theses · 5 institutions

Miniemulsion, emulsion, and dispersion polymerization systems frequently fail when elevated monomer phase viscosity triggers massive latex coagulation. Furthermore, inadequate stabilization and slow polymerization kinetics allow particles to coalesce, aggregate prematurely, or form ill-defined microscale networks instead of discrete nanoparticles.

Tried and failed

free radical polymerisation with chemical initiators applied to nanoparticle encapsulation in hydrogels. Outcome: unstable. Reason: slow polymerisation kinetics allowed particles to aggregate before the matrix gelled

Effect Of Probe Characteristics And Hydrogel Structure On Single Nanoparticle Dynamics · Penn

Tried and failed

incorporating polymer-grafted nanoreinforcements via miniemulsion polymerization applied to waterborne acrylic latex films. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: failed to improve tensile strength, strain at break, or storage modulus relative to neat polymer latex

Incorporating cellulose nanocrystals into waterborne acrylic coatings towards eco-friendly formulations · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

symmetric polymer-grafted nanoparticles as emulsion stabilizers applied to stabilizing immiscible liquid emulsions. Outcome: unstable. Reason: insolubility of symmetric polymer shell in one of the emulsion phases prevented interfacial stabilization

Precise Synthesis, Characterization, and Applications of Nonlinear Polymers with Varied Architectures · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

continuous monomer feeding in emulsion polymerization applied to thermoresponsive hydrogel nanoparticles. Outcome: worse than baseline. Reason: particle size growth plateaued, yielding insufficient particle dimensions for effective infrared transmittance modulation

Disordered Optics for Multidimensional Information Processing · MIT

Tried and failed

incorporating functionalized nanoparticles in miniemulsion polymerization applied to waterborne acrylic nanocomposite latex synthesis. Outcome: unstable. Reason: elevated monomer phase viscosity caused massive latex coagulation during polymerization

Incorporating cellulose nanocrystals into waterborne acrylic coatings towards eco-friendly formulations · Georgia Tech

Tried and failed

solution polymerisation in polar organic solvents applied to crosslinked polyester dimethacrylate nanoparticle synthesis. Reason: failed to yield discrete nanoparticles without aqueous precipitation driving phase separation

Design, synthesis, and analysis of crosslinked polymeric nanoparticles for drug delivery applications · Imperial

Lost to a baseline

P-H1 (MMA-based diblock) showed lower emulsion stability (lower fraction of cream phase resolved) than BuMA, HeMA, and LMA diblock copolymers.

Novel polymeric surfactants to stabilise emulsions · Imperial

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Rejected direct copolymerization of unprotected hydrophilic monomers in the emulsion core due to formation of microscale polymer networks/aqueous phase polymerization; substituted with TMS-protected monomers (TMS-HEMA).

A biodegradable pH-responsive carrier system for targeted siRNA delivery in inflammatory bowel diseases and cancer · UT Austin

Considered and rejected

Considered and rejected: Poly(4-vinylpyridine) homopolymer was rejected in favor of poly(4-vinylpyridine)-co-styrene (P4VP-r-PS, 90:10) to prevent emulsion coalescence during solvent evaporation.

Ring-opening Metathesis Polymerization for the Creation of Responsive Colloids and Surfaces · MIT

Tried and failed

UV-initiated free-radical inverse emulsion polymerization applied to hydrogel nanoparticle synthesis. Outcome: unstable. Reason: produced non-uniform particle sizes, high batch-to-batch variability, and severe particle aggregation

Itaconic acid-based pH-responsive nanoscale hydrogels for the oral delivery of high isoelectric point proteins · UT Austin

Left open by the authors

Problems the authors named and did not get to.

Left open

Model and control phase separation kinetics and domain uniformity in interpenetrating polymer networks using controlled radical polymerization methods. Blocker: Requires a polymer synthesis wet lab to perform and validate controlled radical polymerization experiments

Light-based mechanical patterning in soft matter materials · UT Austin

Left open

Conduct in vivo animal model testing of APGD for functional soft tissue repair such as cartilage, muscle, vasculature, or skin. Blocker: Requires wet lab synthesis of APGD polymer and in vivo animal testing facilities

3D Printed Biodegradable And Shape Memory Polymer Poly(Glycerol Dodecanedioate) (PGD) For Soft Tissue Reconstruction · Georgia Tech

Left open

Toughen soft, elastic, and functional polyether networks using advanced polymer network design strategies. Blocker: Requires wet lab chemical synthesis and mechanical testing of polyether networks

Leveraging living copolymerizations as a tool to tailor the architecture and mechanical properties of polymer networks · UT Austin

Left open

Fabricate a reliable interpenetrating polymer network hydrogel based on the inferred extracellular matrix protein ratios. Blocker: Requires a wet lab and materials chemistry/tissue engineering fabrication apparatus to synthesize the hydrogel

Inferring dynamic extracellular matrix composition of the thymus: towards a biomimetic scaffold for T cell culture · Harvard

Left open

Apply non-toxic, heavy-atom-free thionaphthalimide photopolymers to fabricate biocompatible tissue scaffolds. Blocker: Requires a wet chemistry and biomaterials laboratory for photopolymerization and biocompatibility testing

A guide to photocuring catalyst selection · UT Austin

Left open

Develop branching metathesis polymerization by increasing selectivity between alkyne addition and monomer cycloaddition to synthesize hyperbranched polymers. Blocker: Requires wet lab chemical synthesis, polymerization equipment, and Grubbs ruthenium catalysts

The design and application of functional enyne reagents in metathesis polymerization · Georgia Tech

Left open

Synthesize and evaluate APGD co-polymers to reduce in vitro cytotoxicity and tune mechanical properties for soft-hard interfaces. Blocker: Requires a wet chemistry and biomaterials lab for polymer synthesis, photocuring, mechanical testing, and in vitro cytotoxicity assays

3D Printed Biodegradable And Shape Memory Polymer Poly(Glycerol Dodecanedioate) (PGD) For Soft Tissue Reconstruction · Georgia Tech

Left open

Graft polymers onto poly[[(4-fluorophenyl)sulfonyl]-1,4-phenylene] core via nucleophilic aromatic substitution to synthesize star and branched architectures. Blocker: Requires a wet chemistry laboratory and physical chemical reagents to perform polymer synthesis and grafting reactions

Synthesis and characterization of soluble poly(p-phenylene) derivatives made via Ni(0)-catalyzed coupling of aromatic dichlorides · Iowa State

Left open

Develop synthetic polymer tissue surrogates with controlled viscosity to replicate temporary wound cavity expansion and radial cracking under ballistic impact. Blocker: Requires materials synthesis laboratory and physical ballistic testing apparatus.

Predicting blast injury to the torso · Imperial

Left open

Perform cytotoxicity testing and biocompatibility assays on thermoresponsive methacrylic terpolymers near body temperature. Blocker: Requires wet lab cell culture facilities and physical synthesis of the terpolymer samples

Self-assembled block copolymers: micelles, polymersomes and gels · Imperial

Checking a claim in this area?

We can run the same search on any method or claim. If nothing turns up, we will say so, and that proves nothing on its own.